Tuesday, September 21, 2010

On Mental Disorders, Part One

One of the major errors that people make when thinking of DSM mental disorders and the like is to think of them as diseases. While this is undoubtedly true for some diagnoses in the DSM, the fact of the matter is that "mental disorder" and "disease" are really very different concepts.

While disease categories are abstractions based on etiology, mental disorders... well, aren't. That isn't even the ideal anymore.

As I discussed in an earlier post, certain conditions must be met for something to be called a disease:
  • It must be an impairment of the normal state of the living animal or plant body or one of its parts.
  • It must interrupt or modify the performance of the organism's vital functions.
  • It must be typically manifested by distinguishing signs and symptoms.
  • It must have a distinguishing etiology (which may be simple or complex).
The conditions for something being called a mental disorder, however, are very different. Unlike with the concept of "disease", however, these are anything but straightforward.

Going to MedLine Plus, for instance, yields the following definition: "a mental or bodily condition marked primarily by sufficient disorganization of personality, mind, and emotions to seriously impair the normal psychological functioning of the individual—called also mental illness."

In other words, while a disease is an abstraction based on etiology, a mental disorder is an abstraction based on symptoms. While a disease is a process which causes its symptoms, a mental disorder is a label which describes them or a description of them. Classification of mental disorders makes no reference to the why, only to the what. They have no explanatory value whatsoever; to say that a psychiatric diagnosis has any explanatory value whatsoever is to commit nominal fallacy.

Even this, however, isn't really satisfying. What, for instance, does "disorganization" mean? How do you decide whether or not something "impair[s] the normal psychological functioning of the individual"? Heck, just what does "normal psychological functioning" mean?

These questions are important because of the "wiggle room" built into these terms. In the DSM-I and II, for instance, homosexuality was considered a mental disorder -- homosexuals were considered "broken" heterosexuals whose attraction to members of their own sex represented an impairment to their functioning qua members of their gender. Another infamous example of this problem featured a doctor who pathologized the desire of slaves to flee their masters (he considered whipping to be curative).

My abnormal psychology textbook provides a somewhat more clear answer: it defines one as "a psychological dysfunction within an individual that is associated with distress or impairment in functioning and a response that is not typical or culturally expected." (p. 2)

This, in turn, breaks down into four parts. To qualify as a mental disorder, a set of symptoms must:
  • Constitute a "psychological dysfunction".
  • Be within the individual.
  • Be associated with distress and/or impairment in functioning.
  • Be associated with (at least one) response that is not typical or culturally expected.

Unfortunately, none of these is quite what it seems. I'll write more on this later, but for now... just keep in mind: a mental disorder is not a disease.

Edit: Corrected an embarassing typo.

Sunday, September 19, 2010

On Stereotypes

One of the kindest, most generous people I know is a homosexual, atheistic skeptic. I mention this not because I'm an atheist (I'm not, certain people's claims to the contrary aside) nor because I'm gay (I'm not), nor because I'm a skeptic (this, at least, I am). I mention this because "kind" and "generous" are very much not part of the stereotypes surrounding atheists, homosexuals, or skeptics.

Despite the stereotypes, however, he is all of these things. In fact, the entire list of traits works together quite well: his skepticism, for instance, means that he investigates charities before he gives to them and tries to make sure that his donations actually go to the people he's supposed to be helping. He's skeptical about the charities he donates to precisely because he genuinely cares. I cannot say the same for many people who donate to religious charities, who often care more about appearances or ideology than genuinely helping.

The prevalent stereotypes, however, would pidgeonhole him as the exact opposite of who he is: atheists are often seen as prototypical sinners, untrustworthy and criminal. Skeptics are seen as cynics at best (true skeptics are anything but). Homosexuals... let's not even go there.

Many of the people who know me will know precisely who I am talking about. There is even a possibility that the person I wrote about will read this blog entry some day. I am not, however, writing this to flatter him.

I am writing this to illustrate the point that stereotypes are often misleading. Worse, they are often wrong -- that is, they very often don't even have a genuine basis in fact, but rather are based solely on prejudice or incomprehension.

If this is the case, why do we persist in stereotyping? Especially now, as we're becoming increasingly aware of the manifold harms and errors perpetuated by this sort of thing -- why do it?

The sad truth of the matter is that, as best we can figure it out, stereotyping is the result of normal, adaptive cognitive mechanisms being used in ways that just don't make sense. People, in general, categorize other people in ways that just don't make sense... and then use these categories to reach conclusions that make even less sense.

While I sadly know the answer to why we do it (it's tied up into the normally-adaptive cognitive processes most people rely on to function), the fact of the matter is that we should be smarter than this. We can be smarter than this.

Just question yourself -- repeatedly. Be careful of over-generalization. Realize that in-group differences almost always exceed between-group differences. Keep in mind that people are people, regardless of anything else. Understand that you can misunderstand. Question yourself -- it bears repeating. Understand that statistical significance and practical significance are very different. Realize that "groups" of people -- however they're defined -- are almost always "fuzzy" statistical constructs. Watch out for logical fallacies. Don't expect perfection, mind... but always try to be right.

Thursday, September 16, 2010

On Donald T

As part of my studies in autism, I've read Kanner's original article multiple times. The case that I've paid the most attention to -- and studied across multiple articles -- is that of "Donald T"... in large part because it was the first. I've followed it across multiple papers, and even spent a while last year looking for any and all available information regarding him in the literature. The most recent information, however, was in a 1971 followup -- after this, there was no real information on what happened to the first person to ever be diagnosed as autistic.

That changed recently. As I found out this morning, reporters for the editorial and literary magazine The Atlantic (which has a really long and interesting history) managed to track Donald T down and wrote a genuinely fascinating article about him.

Go. Read. Then come back.

Finished? Good.

The article's nowhere near perfect. It gets some things wrong. It has some bad information.

Still, Donald himself is the main point... and I don't think that needs any further remark. The main takeaway message remains: At the age of 77, Donald Gray Triplett, the first person to ever be diagnosed as autistic, is doing just fine.

Saturday, August 28, 2010

On Paternalism, Murder, and Genocide

Most people don't think of paternalism and murder as compatible. The same could be said for paternalism and genocide. The fact of the matter is that there's nothing incompatible about the concepts.

Paternalism is an attitude. Murder and genocide are actions. They're completely different things.

To commit paternalistic murder, all you have to do is to kill someone because you believe they're better off dead -- to kill them "for their own good". To commit paternalistic genocide, you simply have to generalize this to a demographic group.

It's a sad commentary on the state of things in the world of disability that we have to seriously worry about this intersection.

Friday, August 27, 2010

I Always Want to Be Right (And You Should, Too)

I always want to be right. When I say this, I don't mean that I want to win arguments. That's not being right -- that's having other people tell you you're right. I mean that I want my beliefs to reflect reality. I want all of my beliefs to reflect reality -- if not perfectly, then at least as fully and completely as possible.

I do not want to believe I can fly when I can't. The practical consequences of this are perhaps best described by the term "splat".

I do not want to believe that a cure for cancer works when it doesn't. The practical consequences of this are paid in wasted money and unnecessary side effects. By the same token, however, I don't want to believe that a cure doesn't work when it does. The practical consequences of this are commonly referred to as "dying in horrific agony". Selecting an effective (and helpful) treatment or cure is one of the hardest -- and most important -- parts of medicine.

I do not want reality to conform to my existing beliefs. That idea -- the foolish wishing for what I tend to derisively call "magic god powers" -- may make for a nice fantasy on occasion, but is usually a waste of time. I want my beliefs to conform to reality. I want to believe what is true, not for reality to follow from what I believe.

I do not want others to sit back and say nothing when I express an inaccurate belief. If they do so, I lose the opportunity to correct my beliefs. I fully understand that the price of being right is admitting that you have been wrong. I accept and eagerly pay this price. Metaphorical humble pie may taste awful, but it's very good for you.

I do not want others to hold back in debate. I want to hear the best, most valid arguments that the people I'm debating can put forth -- and I want them to support these arguments as well as they can. I, in turn, will do the same. I will hold my position with the best arguments I can come up with (as the circumstances allow) in hopes of drawing out the best, most thorough counterarguments possible. If I did otherwise, I would deprive myself of evidence and reasoning that could help me develop a better, more informed view of the issue we're debating. If I "win", so be it. If I "lose", so be it. Either way, I'll be using the reasoning and evidence to reevaluate my position... and will very often change it.

Of course, this changing isn't always obvious. I usually reevaluate my position after the debate... and I often play "devil's advocate", offering forth arguments that I don't really believe (but can't easily counter) in order to draw out a precious -- and useful -- counterargument.

I don't want to reach premature final judgment... and my beliefs tend to be more probability estimates regarding the possibility of something being true than actual beliefs that something is true. Truly wanting to be right means being comfortable with the limitations of one's knowledge.

And, in the end, as I reflect on my attitudes and my desire to be right... I can't help but think that the world would be a better place if more people desired to be right, too.

Thursday, August 5, 2010

"Words to the Wise"

As I write this, I am sitting in a computer lab with a copy of Thomas Szasz's "Words to the Wise". It's an utterly fascinating collection of quotes and sound-bites on a wide-ranging collection of topics by one of the most controversial authors in the field of clinical psychology. Some of the quotes I agree with; others I don't. All, however, are thoughts worth considering. Despite the format, it's one of the most thought-provoking books I've seen in a long time.

Ten of the quotes more relevant to today's autism issues:


If a person ingests a drug prohibited by legislators and claims that it makes him feel better, that proves that he's an addict.

If he ingests a drug prescribed by psychiatrists and claims that it makes him feel better, that proves that mental illness is a biomedical disease.


When and why do we say that a behavior is caused rather than willed?

We say that chemicals in the brain cause depression and suicide; but we don't say that chemicals in the ovaries or testicles cause lust and marriage.


The child cannot match the adult in most accomplishments. Hence, we reward him for effort as well as achievement. Yet, the child must learn that what counts in life is not effort but achievement. The child over-rewarded for effort may grow up to seek approval for trying instead of for succeeding. This dooms him to failure. If he succeeds, he succeeds only at trying hard. If he fails, he fails miserably.


When a woman finds having a fetus in her body annoying, she can abort it by taking an abortifacient drug or having a surgical abortion.

When a woman finds having a child in her home annoying, she can abort his persona by having a child psychiatrist give him a chemical straitjacket.


Diagnoses are not diseases.
Diagnoses are names, human fabrications.
Diseases are phenomena, facts of nature.


Demonstrable bodily lesion is the gold standard of medical diagnosis. Without practical convertability into gold, the value of paper money rests only on faith. Without conceptual convertability into bodily lesion, the diagnosis of disease rests only on faith.


A patient with cancer says: "If I had refused my surgeon's suggestion that I have my tumor removed, the cancer would have killed me."
A patient with depression says: "If my psychiatrist had let me refuse the electroshock treatment he recommended, I would have killed myself."
The difference between these two sentences sums up the difference between bodily illness and mental illness.


Three principal rules of conduct:

1. The Golden Rule: Do onto others as you want them to do unto you.

2. The Rule of Respect: Do unto others as they want you to do unto them.

3. The Rule of Paternalism: Do unto others as you in your superior wisdom know ought to be done unto them in their own best interests.


Formerly, debasing the Other by calling him a "nigger" was considered politically correct: the speaker was viewed as a protector of the race or nation from those bent on defiling it.
Today, debasing the Other by calling him "sick" is considered politically correct: the speaker is viewed as a protector of the debased person's best mental health interests and of the nation from a danger to the public health.
Replacing the former rhetoric by the latter is considered moral progress.

Today, everyone claims to be working for the patient's best interests. No wonder the patient is in deep trouble.


Note that I selected these quotes based on relevance, not agreement. I don't, as a matter of fact, agree with a lot of Szasz's thinking. This said, he's an incredibly thought-provoking author. In this blog post, I'm not going to take a stance on any of these. Instead, I'm going to give an "assignment" of sorts to each of my readers.

Read these quotes. Think about them. What does each of them mean? What do they imply? Is this statement -- or implication -- accurate? Is Szasz right or wrong? Why?

Then post an explanation here, answering at least one of these questions for at least one of these quotes. Feel free to do so anonymously or pseudonymously. I don't care about that (although I will delete SPAM posts or personal attacks). If you aren't the first to reply to this, also reply to at least one of the previous replies.

My own replies here will be mostly playing "devil's advocate", issuing responses also intended to make people think and facilitating discussion. Unless I state specifically that a position is my own personal belief, please don't think that it is. I will likely issue arguments against your position even if I agree with it.

The point, after all, is to get people thinking about this sort of thing.

In addition to the obvious, this exercise should give you a pretty good idea of why I highly reccommend this book. It has nothing to do with agreement (although I strongly agree with both the contents and sentiments of many of the quotes, this cannot be said about many others). It has everything to do with the way the book makes you think.

Oh, and it's a treasure mine for anyone who wants quotes for articles, the beginnings of book chapters, and the like. Lots of grade-A quotes here... which is the entire point of the book.

Edit: Added a link.

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

On "Inclusive Resource Lists"

I wrote the following in response to a request for assistance in putting together a directory of resources for the parents of autistic children. I've edited the formatting and changed a few details to reflect the formatting options I have here on Blogger; other than a few formatting things (parentheses and quotes replaced with a block quote, etc.) and one spelling correction, the message remains substantially unchanged.

In other words, you want to create the resource-list version of Wheeler's (2003) thought experiment.
To quote:
Suppose a medical centre were to propose creating a programme in 'unproven and dubious medicine'. In this programme, physicians would learn how to give patients not only conventional treatments, but also treatments not known to be safe and effective. Some of these would have plausible mechanisms of action, but others would make no sense. The treatments would include experimental drugs of unknown purity. There would be research concerning the methods, but in the meantime the methods would be used before the results were known. Patients would have the benefits of both worlds – treatments that work and treatments that probably don't work.

A programme with such a title would find little acceptance. But change the name to 'integrative medicine', downplay the lack of evidence, claim that it deals with healing the person and employs new paradigms, and for some reason there is much greater acceptance. (p. 8)
You want to list people who make their living chemically castrating autistic children in the middle of people who've dedicated their lives to helping treat actual disease; you want to list people who make their living torturing kids next to people who've spent their lives trying to protect children. You want to list fear-mongering hate propaganda next to legitimate resources on parent education.

Err... no. I have no intention of helping with the development of such a "list". There are more than enough of them already.
This sort of thing is a tremendous problem in the autism world.

What would people make of a "resource list" that deliberately put legitimate stockbrokers and investment funds next to known con-artists? Yet, for some reason, people seem to think that lists that do this sort of thing are okay for parents of autistic children.

Some of this comes from the postmodernist belief in constructed reality. If you don't believe in an objective reality -- if people agreeing that something is true is enough to make it true -- then the question of what's actually going on is both meaningless and irrelevant within your paradigm. Despite what postmodernism would say, however, ignoring objective facts and attempting to construct your own reality independent from them is better known as "self-delusion" and acting on this sort of thing tends to produce tragic results. Quite frankly, this sort of attitude is patently absurd.

Despite this, however, many parents somehow view fraudulent resources as equal to real ones, "alternative" medicine as equal to real medicine, and hate propaganda which gives them false hope as superior to truths which offers them real hope (if at the expense of accepting things they don't want to hear).

I don't get it. I really, literally, don't... at least on an emotional level. Intellectually, maybe (at least somewhat), but that's the difference between "knowing" and "understanding".

Unfortunately, postmodernism only accounts for part of the problem. Bigotry, normocentric bias, and countless other factors also contribute. The results, however, speak for themselves. Parents of newly-diagnosed children usually lack the ability to distinguish between legitimate and illegitimate resources. They are at their most desperate, their most confused, and their most emotional. They seek a helping hand from anyone who offers it... and rarely notice the metaphorical dagger aimed at their backs. They are prime victims for frauds and con-men.

Many of them get wiser as time passes. Many of them learn the skills they should have been taught from the beginning... but it's easy for irreparable harm to have been done by then. If they're lucky, they'll only have been scammed out of money. If they're less so... the potential dangers are difficult to underestimate. In countless ways and for countless reasons, fake help is worse than no help.

I'd be more than happy to help someone assemble a genuine, reliable resource list. I will not, however, help with this sort of "project".